Friday, 18 January 2019

THE FULL STORY ON THE MENZGOLD SCAM AND THE BLAME GAME



By Iddi Muhayu-Deen

Whereas many Ghanaians and government alike are sympathizing with customers of Menzgold especially the unsuspecting ones most of whom are on the brink of losing their life-time investments and are calling on the relevant State actors to do the needful, the biggest opposition party in Ghana, the NDC, would rather see this as yet another opportunity to make political capital. In a very characteristic fashion, the NDC, led by their National Communications Officer, Sammy Gyamfi, would want Ghanaians to blame President Akufo-Addo and the NPP government for the predicaments of Menzgold and all its customers for some unfathomable reasons.

Sammy Gyamfi also accuses His Excellency President Akufo-Addo and the NPP government of complicity in this Menzgold saga and attempting to cover up their involvement through some state-sponsored actions. Ordinarily, I would ignore Sammy Gyamfi, because, it is clear that, his relevance in the NDC is measured based on the amount of vitriol and acidic propaganda he is able to spew at the person of President Akufo-Addo and the NPP, and so, he’s only doing his job. I am however unable to resist the temptation to respond to him and set the records straight particularly on his desperate attempt to politicise this otherwise sensitive issue.

SAMMY GYAMFI’S INCONSISTENCY

The same Sammy Gyamfi, who, recently, was all over the place, slamming the NPP government for seeking to collapse NAM1’s business (Menzgold), is today, making a gargantuan u’turn accusing government and President Akufo-Addo in particular for promoting the business of Menzgold. When you elect such a walking contradiction as your National Communications Officer, you certainly should not expect anything less. I am sure you’ve watched and listened to him on Asempa fm and elsewhere blowing both hot and cold on the same subject of Menzgold. 

THE POLITICS OF PICTURE AND ENDORSEMENT

Sammy Gyamfi and the NDC are claiming that because NAM1 has a picture with President Akufo-Addo, it is prima facie evidence of the president’s complicity and open endorsement of NAM1’s business operations. How pathetic!! So, public figures and officials can no longer take pictures with other persons, and if they did, it meant they endorsed the activities of those other persons? Is this what the NDC has been reduced to? Where would such sheer desperation and kindergarten politics take us to?

If, for being seen in a photo with NAM1, it meant President Akufo-Addo endorsed and promoted the works of NAM1, then former President Mahama also endorsed homosexuality, because, he is seen in many pictures and at close intervals with Andrew Solomon, who is widely described as the founder and president of the Association of Gays and Lesbians in the World. In fact, in the case of President Mahama and Andrew Solomon, their relationship goes beyond the many pictures they took, and as the former President himself once put it in disagreeing with his Information and Media Relations Minister, Mahama Ayariga, Andrew Solomon was his close friends with whom they did many things together, and indeed, when he was launching his maiden book, “My First Coup d’état” in the US, he, [President Mahama] made Andrew Solomon the Chairman for that auspicious occasion.

Also, going by Sammy Gyamfi and his NDC’s infantile logic, His Eminence the National Chief Imam as well as His Royal Highness the Asantehene, just like President Akufo-Addo, have also endorsed NAM1’s business, because he [NAM1] has photos with them. Equally, the Multimedia Group, Media-General, GBC, EIB Network and indeed all the media stations that run adverts for Menzgold have all endorsed NAM1’s modus operandi and are therefore his accomplices in this unfolding saga. That’s Sammy Gyamfi and the NDC for you.

THE NAKED LIES

Contrary to the NDC’s claim that Menzgold has over 2.8m customers with some GHc200m investment with the company, records have it that Menzgold actually has less than 10,000 customers with less than GHc100m worth of investment. It is also a palpable falsehood the NDC’s claim that NAM1 was a financier to the NPP’s 2016 campaign and indeed Sammy Gyamfi and his propaganda cohorts have till date not been able to adduce a scintilla of evidence to substantiate their claims.  

MENZGOLD OPERATIONS AND THE BLAME GAME

The NDC says we should blame the NPP government for allowing Menzgold to operate, and failing to take the necessary steps to protect the customers. Let us subject this claim to FACTS CHECK. First of all, it is a fact that Menzgold was licensed in 2013 when it started operation by which time the NDC was in government. Apart from the issuance of a red alert, the NDC government did absolutely nothing to clampdown on the operations of Menzgold even when it became clear that they were operating beyond the remit of the license they were granted by the Minerals Commission.

So, Menzgold had a safe haven to operate for 4 years during the Mahama administration. That’s the record of the NDC in stopping the Menzgold scam and protecting its customers. With such records, you would understand why almost all the major Ponzi Schemes witnessed in Ghana happened during the NDC reign including the infamous US Tilapia, DKM, R5, Bamask and Pyram among several others.

Contrasting this with the NPP’s commitment in relation to dealing with the Menzgold saga, the difference is overwhelmingly clear. To start with, immediately the NPP came into office, the Bank of Ghana, in July 2017, cautioned the general public and warned Menzbank to stop taking further deposits. In a smart move, the company changed its name to Menzgold and set up a subsidiary by name “Brew Marketing Limited” where clients were directed to go and purchase gold and deposit same with Menzgold for monthly dividend of 7 to 10%. Minerals Commission, after its investigation, wrote to Menzgold in September 2017, stating that Brew Marketing Limited had not been registered as a licence buying agent.   

Also, after a joint operation with the Bank of Ghana and the Minerals Commission in June 2018, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) went hard on Menzgold describing their operation as one of capital market dealings, which it did not have licence thus contravening the Securities Industries Act, 2016 (Act 929) as well as the Specialized Deposit-Taking Act, 2016 (Act 930). Accordingly, Menzgold was ordered to stop operation in relation to taking new contracts. For the records, Menzgold was not ordered to stop paying dividends to existing customers, but was only asked to stick to what its license provided while maintaining its existing contractual obligations.

It is worthy of note that all these statutory bodies (EOCO, SEC, PMMC, Minerals Commission and the Bank of Ghana) and laws existed during the NDC administration when Menzgold operated for good 4 years. There was no conscious effort by officialdom to check the operations of the company and so, they were allowed to operate in a non-regulatory regime duping more and more unsuspecting customers with their “rob Peter and pay Paul” Ponzi Scheme.

WHY EOCO DIDN’T ORDER THE FREEZING OF NAM1’S ACCOUNTS AND SEIZURE OF HIS PROPERTIES

Sammy Gyamfi makes the point that EOCO should be faulted for failing to order the immediate freezing and seizure of NAM1’s accounts and properties when the EOCO Act, 2010 (Act 804) clothes it with such powers. To him and his NDC, so long as the law clothes a statutory body with certain powers, the body can exercise such powers in any manner it deems fit without recourse to due process. Sammy Gyamfi pretends to be unaware that the exercise of discretionary power is subject to the elaborate provisions of Article 23 and 296 of the 1992 Constitution which provisions were enunciated by the Supreme Court in a number of decided cases including Awuni v WAEC and Abu Ramadan v EC and Okudzeto Ablakwa(2) v AG(2).

Yet, Sammy Gyamfi, whom we are told is a lawyer, does not know this? God save the legal profession. The point should be made that EOCO has now been able to freeze NAM1’s accounts because it has now been established beyond equivocation that Menzgold was engaged in some fishy deals culminating in loss of depositors’ funds and the accompanying public protestations. Indeed, an Accra High Court recently dismissed Menzgold’s suit challenging SEC’s regulatory jurisdictions over its operations.

WHY DID EOCO GRANT BAIL TO NAM1 AND FAIL TO CONFISCATE HIS PASSPORT

EOCO’s invitation and subsequent arrest of NAM1 was as early as August 2018 following a complaint filed by the Bank of Ghana after the banter it had with NAM1, but at which time no prima facie case was established against him. He was therefore entitled to bail even without sureties. It is therefore not surprising that he was granted a self-recognisance bail. There was also no clarity in respect of which laws Menzgold had breached and which statutory body had exclusive jurisdiction over its operations.

Equally, Menzgold was at the time challenging the actions of SEC and the Bank of Ghana in court. In view of this, you would agree that there was no basis for EOCO to have descended heavily on NAM1 to the extent of seizing his passports and refusing to grant him bail. I bet you, if EOCO had acted in such capricious manner, the same Sammy Gyamfi and the NDC would have accused EOCO and by extension the Akufo-Addo government of abusing its powers against innocent businessmen.

GOVERNMENT AIDED NAM1’S ESCAPE  

Having established that NAM1 was deserving of bail based on the law and the circumstances of this case, which bail he was rightly granted by EOCO, why should government be blamed for the conduct of NAM1 in breaching his bail conditions and absconding? In any case, Sammy Gyamfi’s legendary incompetence would not let him know that the ports of Ghana are not the only means through which one can leave the Ghanaian territory. Incompetence would not let Sammy Gyamfi and his NDC know that people can leave this country through any of our many borders (approved or non-approved) without any trace.

CONCLUSION

It is abundantly clear from the foregoing that if we were to politicise this infamous Menzgold scam as the NDC is inviting us to do, then certainly their government [the erstwhile Mahama administration] is to blame, for, first of all, creating this mess and failing to apply the law to protect innocent customers. It is also abundantly clear that, just like the banking sector mess they left behind, this Akufo-Addo government has shown more than enough testicular commitment to dealing with the crisis at all costs including political cost so long as it is in the interest of the nation. In any case, we didn’t vote for a government to go taking popular decisions but decisions that would inure greatly to the benefit of the nation at large even if they appear unpopular today.

As for Sammi Gyamfi, the least said about him the better. It is obvious he would never change so long as you have some desperate politicians in the NDC urging him on. The young man, perhaps, doesn’t know he is being used to do some dirty works of these so called party kingpins while destroying his credibility, if he still has any. Well, let it be told Sammy Gyamfi and his NDC that he cannot fool all the people all the time. Ghanaians are not unintelligent.

Assalamu alaik

Iddi Muhayu-Deen

#ForGodAndCountry